A coral-rock arch under bougainvillea at the lake-view terrace of Pinecrest Gardens. Photo: Ebyabe, CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons

The first years of the Village

Pinecrest started its own police department in 1997, bought the Parrot Jungle land in 2002, and in 2004 elected Gary its second mayor.

Reviewing the charter, 2000–2001

Five years after incorporation, Gary chaired the Charter Revision Commission appointed on December 5, 2000, according to the charter’s historical notes. The Herald described it as “a group of five residents nominated by council members,” with Councilwoman Cindie Blanck serving as a nonvoting member. It sent eight proposed changes to a mail ballot in spring 2001, among them a rule for breaking tie votes and a charter review every six years instead of every ten. Gary called the process “a worthwhile effort.”

The most debated proposal would have lengthened term limits to three terms and 12 years. Gary set out both sides: “They’ve done a great job. On the other hand, there are people out there who want the opportunity to participate and to serve, so that’s really the rub.” Voters turned that proposal down.

Village Charter historical notes; The Miami Herald, April 29, 2001, “Village special election faces Tuesday deadline” (Eunice Ponce, 2E); June 8, 2006, “Clean charter unprecedented act” (Charlene Collazo, 3PP)

“But sometimes just magic happens. And that’s what happened here with the Village of Pinecrest.”

Gary Matzner Twenty years after the founding Village oral history, 2016, at 01:12:21

Pinecrest’s tenth anniversary

When Pinecrest marked its tenth anniversary in March 2006, Gary was its mayor. The Herald’s anniversary profile said he “was one of the first residents involved in the incorporation process with former Pinecrest Mayor Evelyn Greer,” adding: “The two orchestrated meetings with residents to explore breaking away from Miami-Dade County.” His own assessment: “I think we accomplished more than we promised the citizens 10 years ago.”

Greer remembered the founding years as idealistic: “We didn’t hire lobbyists, we didn’t pay ourselves any salary, we just wanted it to be a pure democracy.” Councilwoman Cindie Blanck, a member of the first council, said the original council had envisioned a community center and library and that Gary had moved the project forward. Not every resident was persuaded. Hope Marcus, who had organized against incorporation in 1996, told the paper, “Incorporation just added another layer of government.”

Thousands of residents came to the anniversary celebration at Evelyn Greer Park, where Gary reminisced about the grass-roots effort and said Pinecrest’s dreams of becoming a “small, hometown community” had come true. A 2011 Herald history of the village summed up the founding in one sentence: “Evelyn Greer and Gary Matzner led the incorporation effort.”

The Miami Herald, March 12, 2006, “10 years later, town is a suburban dream” (Kathleen Fordyce, 3PP); March 12, 2006, “How a decade makes a difference” (Kathleen Fordyce, 6PP); March 23, 2006, “Celebrating in style” (Kathleen Fordyce, 3PP); December 1, 2011, “A village in time” (Michelle Hammontree-Garcia, 6SW)

Gary’s Pinecrest record

Gary’s Pinecrest record includes the Village Charter, local police service, land-development control, public parks, Pinecrest Gardens, and a municipal government accountable to local residents.

Pinecrest elected Gary as its second mayor in 2004, and Evelyn Langlieb Greer administered his oath of office on November 3. Removing the five-dollar admission fee at Pinecrest Gardens had been one of his campaign promises, and the council voted to drop it that December. The family remembers it as his first act as mayor, making the land he had helped save free to the public. His term included the community center and library at Pinecrest Gardens, Flagler Grove Park, a renovated Veterans’ Wayside Park, lighting along the Red Road path, and the long-debated effort to bring county water and fire hydrants to homes that relied on wells; when he announced in August 2008 that he would not run again, a project to build the system’s spine and serve about 330 homes was set to begin that October. By his own published accounting he left office in 2008 with the millage rate cut to second-lowest among Miami-Dade’s cities and a record surplus, and with a simple exit line: “All the major things are done.”

Gary helped turn neighborhood concerns into a municipal government, chaired the commission that drafted its charter, helped preserve one of the community’s defining landscapes, and later served as the Village’s second mayor.

Village Clerk milestones; The Miami Herald, September 2004; December 12, 2004, “Admission fee is eliminated” (Kevin Dean); August 10, 2008, “Matzner decides it’s time to move on” (Patricia Mazzei, 4PP); August 10, 2008, “Serota, Lerner enter mayor’s race; deadline is Friday” (Priscilla Greear); Pinecrest Tribune, Nov. 2008 (Gary’s farewell column); Village oral history 01:10-01:16

Timeline, 1997–2008

  1. The Village police department begins patrol

    Local officers assumed patrol responsibility from Miami-Dade County, delivering one of the clearest promises made during the incorporation campaign.

  2. The Village moves to save Parrot Jungle

    Soon after incorporation Gary founded Preserve the Jungle, a nonprofit that raised money, leveraged matching funds, and organized support for the Village’s effort to keep the historic property public as the attraction prepared to leave for Watson Island.

  3. Gary chairs a charter review

    The Charter Revision Commission, which Gary chaired, sent eight proposed changes to a mail ballot in spring 2001, among them a six-year review cycle and a tie-breaking rule. Voters rejected a proposal to lengthen term limits.

  4. The land becomes public

    Pinecrest acquired 13.38 acres of the historic site with Florida Communities Trust assistance, preserving the landscape for public use.

  5. The Jungle becomes Pinecrest Gardens

    The former tourist attraction became a shared civic landscape for gardens, recreation, arts, markets, and community life.

  6. Gary becomes Pinecrest’s second mayor

    Evelyn Greer administered the oath of office. Removing the five-dollar admission fee at Pinecrest Gardens had been one of his campaign promises, and the council voted to drop it that December; the family remembers it as his first act. His term continued the Village’s civic buildout through parks, the community center and library, water infrastructure, and public-space improvements.